May 14th, 2008 (06:45 pm)
Moonlight is cancelled and I personally think it deserved to be. It was a show with a rocky start and a rockier existence. There was no cohesive force or vision behind the show. The show runner's seemed to only know that they wanted Beth and Mick together. Nothing else. The vampire genre is not only overdone but it has been done extremely well before. This show had a chance to break new ground but it focused too little on vampire lore and too much on Beth/Mick - forcing the romance rather than letting it grow naturally. I don't swallow forced romance, I don't like the idea of someone telling me who the "OTP" is, I like to feel a sense of them growing as they interract. I want to feel the chemistry and understand why they fall for each other as I fall for them.
I didn't feel that with Beth/Mick and since the show had nothing else at its core, I didn't feel much for the show. My one moment of regret is that I won't see JD any more but I lived without Brendan Fehr (sorry, BF, not even you could make me watch the trash that is CSI Miami) and I lived without Joshua Jackson. I can live without you, much as it's causing me pangs.
I think JD had nothing to do on this show and it could have been bad for him rather than good. Sure, it gave him exposure, but exposure doing what? It probably would have been better not to be on the show due to the (maybe undeserved) critical acclaim Veronica Mars had. If you're remembered only for your last piece of work in Hollywood, I worry about him being remembered for his spotty performances on Moonlight. Little to work with beneath the surface and not much screen time at all.
I think we'll see Alex O'Loughlin again because it's clear the station loves him. I know we'll see Sophia Myles again and I'm so relieved she isn't on this show any more. I love her as an actress and I hated hating her character. Beth just didn't appeal to me on any level and I know it's not Sophia's fault. It was entirely the writing. I have loved everything else I've seen Sophia in so I felt strange about not liking her in this. (This is the first time it's been crystal clear to me that the writing is to blame for my character-hatred too. In the past actors have been sub-par or a variety of things could have been better. This show? Always the writing. The writing SUCKED ASS)
Yep. So the only one I am worried about is JD. I won't miss it, I won't get frustrated wanting the show to get a real showrunner with clear vision and a capacity to balance themes evenly. The show was never going to get that, it was shot in the foot before it began and now it's just put out of its misery. (How many hackneyed phrases can I string together in a sentence, hey?)
I don't mind saying that if the ratings don't cut it, the show should be cancelled in this instance. This show had zero creative or dynamic spunk that would make it critically acclaimed. It had nothing to offer that we hadn't seen before on numerous vampire shows, done particularly well in Buffy and Angel. Hell, I even liked The House of Frankenstein better. As a used genre it had to do something different that made it pop and sparkle. It didn't. Thus it doesn't fill any of my criteria for renewal other than having cute boys and, sorry, that's not enough to make me watch any show considering how many cute boys exist in Hollywood.
All in all? Good call CBS. I'll miss the bromance but that's all.